Comments on Profile Post by Merrick

MCAD-31078

And when I say one of the best masterings I've ever heard, I mean on any format. It shows the full capabilities of the redbook standard and puts most rock/pop releases to shame.

Looking on discogs, that catalog number appears to be a 1988 reprint of the original 1986 CD, catalog number MCAD-1613, but the masterings are identical.

Two copies for sale here: https://www.discogs.com/Elton-John-Captain-Fantastic-And-The-Brown-Dirt-Cowboy/release/4954361

Makes you wonder what the vinyl flavor would bring to the table?

@ButtUglyJeff I have a US 1st press and it's not nearly as good, but maybe there are better vinyl masterings.

I bought one of those copies you linked to. Wow, you were not kidding. Thanks for the rec.

@Boops I'm really glad to hear you like it! It's an exceptional mastering. Recordings like that make being an audiophile so rewarding.

The mastering is exceptional. Beyond that, I'd never heard this album before and I'm loving it. I don't consider myself an Elton John superfan -- I know his hits but don't even own any of his music. This album is so good.

If you have any other recommendations for CD masters that are this good, Elton John or no, I'd be interested in hearing them.

I'll have to go through my collection and see what else is worth recommending. That mastering really is exceptional in every way, it's hard to match. Also the songwriting and performances are so top notch. It's always been my favorite Elton John album.

Finally got my Discogs account reopened after months and was able to buy this.

Nice! Let us know what you think.

Oh man, finally got this ripped to my music server. I wish all rock/pop albums were done like this.